When it comes to combating acne problems, it is a battle between Proactiv vs Curology vs Hers. But which among these three is the best anti-acne product?
Acne is a serious skin condition that needs to be treated as soon as possible, which is why it is very helpful to have some handy help from trusted and dermatologically tested products like Proactiv, Curology, and Hers.
In a study conducted by the Allied Market Research, it has been found that there is an estimated $10 billion market worldwide when it comes to acne treatment. This data shows that more and more people are battling acne in their day to day life.
Furthermore, in the United States alone, it has been found that there are about 60 million people who were affected by acne when they were teenagers. Apparently, 20% of these people continue to battle with acne as they reached adulthood.
According to research, adult women tend to suffer more from acne as compared to adult men. In fact, in 2007 data from Science Daily, more than 35% of women had acne when they were in their 30s as compared to 20% men with the same age range. Meanwhile, 26% of women who were in their 40s were suffering from acne, while only 12% of men in their 40s go through the same ordeal.
With such data of people who are suffering or are affected by acne, it is not surprising why more and more products are coming up to specifically help prevent or fight off acne problems. But the question is, which among these anti-acne products is the best?
With that said, we are comparing three of the major acne-fighting brands in the market today. Will look into each product and what they are promising, and hopefully, determine which among these three the best is when it comes to combating acne problems.
It’s indeed a battle between Proactiv vs Curology vs Hers. But first…
WHAT IS ACNE?
Before dissecting the products we mentioned earlier, we thought it’s just right to first help you understand what acne is all about. After all, fighting off the problem becomes easier when you fully understand what it is in the first place.
It is probably safe to say that acne is a normal thing. A lot of people suffer from it, especially during the puberty stage.
According to WebMD, acne begins when “greasy secretions from the skin’s sebaceous glands (oil glands) plug the tiny openings for hair follicles (plugged pores)“. Furthermore, it explains, “If the openings are large, the clogs take the form of blackheads: small, flat spots with dark centers. If the openings stay small, the clogs take the form of whiteheads: small, flesh-colored bumps.”
Either way though, it can lead to swollen, tender inflammations or pimples or nodules.
Acne has been tagged as a “curse of adolescence” with about 20% of all cases happens among adults. It usually starts between the ages of 10 and 13. Unfortunately, it can get worse on people with oily skin. Moreover, experts say that teenage acne can last for up to 10 years.
As we have mentioned earlier, while it does occur on men, women are the ones who are mostly affected by acne especially those who are in their 30s and beyond.
WHAT CAUSES ACNE?
While the cause of acne is not really that fully understood even by experts, here are some of the common reasons that people associate with acne flare outs:
When a person hits puberty, hormone production increases. In fact, during this stage, both girls and boys produce a high level of androgens, which is the male hormones that include testosterone. The testosterone is the one responsible for signaling the body to create more sebum, which refers to the oil being produced in the skin’s oil glands.
Bacteria have also been associated with acne. Some people believe that not maintaining good hygiene can greatly affect the skin, which can lead to acne.
Apparently, extra sebum clogs the openings to hair follicles particularly the ones on the face, neck, chest, as well as the back. It is in these clogged follicles where bacteria usually grow
HOW TO TREAT ACNE?
There are several ways to help treat acne. However, the treatments differ in the severity of the case.
For mild acne or for prevention purposes, at-home care usually works. Here are some at-home remedies that will help you prevent or get rid of acne:
- Clean your skin every day using a mild soap to help get rid of excess oil and dirt.
- Make sure to shampoo your hair on a regular basis, and ensure that it’s always out of your face.
- Use water-based makeup or labeled “noncomedogenic” (not pore-clogging) only.
- Avoid squeezing or picking pimples, which spreads bacteria and excess oil.
- Avoid wearing hats or tight headbands.
- Avoid touching your face especially without washing your hands first.
Meanwhile, for those suffering from a more serious acne condition, medication is highly advised. Below are some of the over-the-counter acne medications that are available in the market today. Take note that most of these medications have ingredients that can help kill bacteria, as well as in reducing oil on the skin. These medications include:
- Sulfur – a natural ingredient that comes with a distinctive smell that is commonly found in some cleansers, masks, as well as lotions.
- Resorcinol – a not-so-common ingredient that is used in removing dead skin cells.
- Benzoyl Peroxide – an ingredient that is usually present in a lot of acne gels and creams including Proactiv, Curology, and Hers. It is particularly used to help dry out existing pimples, at the same time, preventing new ones from forming. It also helps kill acne-causing bacteria.
- Salicylic acid – an ingredient that is normally used in soaps and acne washes. It particularly helps in preventing pores from clogging.
There are some cases though that OTC medications are not enough to cure or prevent acne. For severe acne cases, you may opt to seek medical advice. By doing so, the dermatologist can prescribe certain medications that will help reduce acne symptoms, as well as prevent scars. These types of medications include:
- Oral or topical antibiotics help lessen inflammation, as well as kill the bacteria that is responsible for causing pimples.
- Prescription topical creams like retinoic acid or prescription-strength benzoyl peroxide that are usually stronger compared to over-the-counter treatments, which helps in reducing oil production.
PROACTIV VS CUROLOGY VS HERS: BACKGROUND AND OVERVIEW OF EACH PRODUCT
Now that we have already tackled what acne is all about, what causes it from happening, and the possible at home as well as over-the-counter medications, let’s proceed to compare three of the most well-known products/brands when it comes to fighting off acne.
Let’s dissect what makes Proactiv, Curology, and Hers a stand out from the rest, and which among Proactiv vs Curology vs Hers is the best.
Common Anti-Acne Ingredients
Just before we proceed with dissecting each product, allow us to share with you first some of the anti-acne ingredients that are present in either Proactiv, Curology, or Hers. These ingredients include:
In an article entitled, “Management of Acne” by John Kraft, MD and Anatoli Freiman, MD, it says that benzoyl peroxide is a bacterial agent that helps prevent the resistance of acne-causing bacteria to antibiotics. As mentioned earlier, it also helps dry out existing pimples, as well as in preventing new pimples from coming out. It also helps in unclogging pores.
Retinoids are derivatives of Vitamin A. It helps acne in three significant ways, which include: regulating skin cell turnover to help avoid dead skin cells from blocking pores, it helps clear existing blemishes, and it also helps keep inflammation at bay.
Salicylic Acid helps exfoliate the surface of the skin. It sloughs off the top layer, and then works deep in the pores — particularly unclogging debris and reducing sebum secretion. It also helps get rid of whiteheads and blackheads.
This ingredient is like a magic potion. It helps improve tone and dullness of skin, as well as reduce unwanted wrinkles and fine lines. It also works well in the general improvement of the texture of the skin. Furthermore, it also goes along well with other usual skincare ingredients. Thus, making it an ideal addition to your daily routine.
It is an antibiotic that is used in treating a wide spectrum of bacterial infections. Normally, clindamycin is used as a topical treatment. However, in cases of severe acne, doctors may prescribe it as an oral medication. Clindamycin comes with an anti-inflammatory effect, thus, making it able to calm down redness, as well as swelling.
Azelaic acid works to unclog pores, as well as helps in polishing skin textures. Azelaic acid is an exfoliant that helps get rid of spots, discoloration, as well as blemishes.
Now, let’s proceed to each of the products…
Proactiv has been around for over 20 years already. It was first introduced in the market back in the mid-’90s. Proactiv is popular because of its three-step acne clearing system, which includes a renewing cleanser, revitalizing toner, and repairing treatment.
More so, the product takes pride in using benzoyl peroxide that is much more finely milled as compared to other over-the-counter creams. Needless to say, with such composition, it allows the product to work deeper into the pores.
At present, Proactiv offers three different acne solution sets. Each set comes with a distinct formula or specific active ingredients. The second set that they have introduced comes with salicylic acid, while the latest ProactivMD uses Adapalene.
Learn more about Proactiv in this video review shared by Youtuber, Chas Martinez:
Curology also comes with a daily three-step skincare routine. The second step of the daily routine is a customized formula, which means it is specifically designed according to your skin’s needs (acne, clogged pores, wrinkles, skin texture or firmness).
Before ordering your bottle of Curology product, you are required to take a quiz that will help in determining the kind of treatment your skin needs. You will also be paired with a medical provider to chat with and help ensure you get the right doses of each active ingredient.
Hers basically offers a simple skincare routine that will help clear breakouts.
Hers offers a program that comes with just two steps — one in the morning and the other at night. For just a minimal cost, you can meet with a physician who will help formulate the right treatment for your skin. Every time you purchase a refill of your skincare products, you will have a follow-up session with the doctor. This helps ensure that someone is checking your skin’s progress. At the same time, it helps reduce the chances of side effects.
PROACTIV VS CUROLOGY VS HERS: PRODUCT COMPARISON
|AREAS FOR COMPARISON||PROACTIV||CUROLOGY||HERS|
|Program||Three-step daily routine specifically designed to fight off acne||Three-step daily routine with a customized formula based on what your skin needs||Morning and night solutions that are individually formulated to fight off acne|
|Active Ingredients||Benzoyl peroxide
|Prescription||Not Needed||Yes, you will need a prescription, however, consultation is already included in your subscription.||Yes, you will need a prescription. The consultation is matched with your subscription.|
|Price Per Month||Starts at $19.95 with either 30 or 90-day subscription||Starts at $19.95 per month||Starts at $44 plus a $5 medical fee|
|Shipping Cost||Free shipping if you choose the 90-day plan||Free shipping for their 60-day plan||Free|
|Trial Period||60-day money-back guarantee plus $5 off intro kits||Free trial for your first month||Pay for only $5 for the first month|
PROACTIV VS CUROLOGY VS HERS: PURCHASING ONLINE
All three companies offer great skincare solutions particularly in battling acne. It’s perhaps safe to say that what these companies offer is so much better as compared to those sold by drugstores, as well as beauty boutiques.
Proactiv, Curology, and Hers have created a system that uses ingredients that go along with each other, working well to help solve acne problems. Needless to say, getting rid of the guesswork of what products to buy for a specific skincare problem, and when to use the product or products.
In both Curology and Hers, they let you connect with a doctor to consult with online. If you come to think of it, it’s very convenient given the kind of lifestyle we all have these days. With online consultation, you are spared from booking a doctor’s appointment, having to take a leave from work, and of course, the expensive copay. Instead, you get to receive a professional acne treatment advice right at the comfort of your home. Needless to say, they allow you to speak to the consultants throughout the treatment process.
Overall, Curology and Hers make it so much easier and cheaper to begin and maintain a treatment plan that is formulated by legit dermatologists.
Furthermore, purchasing these products online helps you save a lot of money. All three companies make their products available for less than a visit to the doctor, which makes it a lot cheaper as their packages already include the skincare itself.
When it comes to shipping fees, all three companies offer a subscription service that delivers straight to your home for free. Needless to say, you do not have to worry about running out of products, because by subscribing, you are ensured of getting the products you need on time every time.
PROACTIV VS CUROLOGY VS HERS: CUSTOMER REVIEWS
Upon looking at and reading customer reviews, we have to say that all three companies are being commended for their products.
Here are some of the customer reviews on Proactive, Curology, as well as Hers for your reference:
Clear skin within days
After using many other products I finally purchased Proactiv. I could see the difference after 2 uses! It even proved itself worth when I didn’t have any breakouts during my menstrual cycle! I love this product and would recommend it to anyone! Thanks, Proactiv!
Where has Curology been my whole life?! Honestly, this is the best thing that’s ever come into my life. My face has drastically cleared up since I started using the formula they sent me, AND I was even on my period!
Usually, when that happens I’m stuck in breakout city for at least 2 weeks, but instead, my face is clearing up. I don’t know how this formula is different than anything else I’ve ever tried, but I’m not complaining. I am SO happy with how this has worked and encourage any skeptics out there to give this a try because I haven’t felt this confident EVER!
– Natalie Hendricks
I had used a competitor for a bit before switching to a prescription tretinoin cream since I developed an allergy to the base change of the competitor. I had an issue with what modern wanted to prescribe, then lemon aid health would no longer do my scripts after doing them before, and managed to find this place. I have no problem with the base ingredients at all, which is great. But I wish the tretinoin amount were aligned with the studies .05% (what I was using) as they only go to .02%. I also do wish they’d have Azelaic Acid included as well. The other alternative is derma care whom I am told is no longer doing prescription ingredients for new patients (don’t know why). All in all, I do recommend for clindamycin but I think it’s a bit expensive for that alone, hopefully, they increase their tret amounts. Shipping took a week but the Dr seems friendly and thorough.
Ability to get prescription acne meds without phenoxyethanol or comedogenic ingredients.
Low tretinoin amounts
– Whitney Quinn
PROACTIV VS CUROLOGY VS HERS: THE VERDICT
Overall, we have to say that the three companies offer amazing products that help fight off acne. To be more specific though, we thought Proactiv is best for those who are just starting with acne treatments. Technically speaking, Proactiv uses over-the-counter ingredients. What makes the difference is that they processed it in a way that they may work more efficiently than other anti-acne products.
Meanwhile, we like the fact that Curology offers a personalized solution to a wide variety of skincare needs. Curology’s formula can be customized depending on what your skin needs are. Needless to say, their formula can treat more than just acne. We also appreciate the fact that Curology offers financial assistance particularly among teens and young adults who qualify for aid.
Just like Curology, Hers offers online assessment by a dermatologist. The company formulates solutions with prescription-grade ingredients. Unlike the first two companies, they make things a little simpler by sending you just two bottles for use during the day and at night time.
FINAL THOUGHTS ON PROACTIV VS CUROLOGY VS HERS
We have to commend all three companies as they offer such convenient but at the same time effective products that help address acne problems.
It’s really hard to say which one is the best because, at the end of the day, it’s a matter of choosing which one is the best for your skin type. Thus, the final verdict goes to you, the user of the product.